We reach more than 65,000 registered users in Dec!!

Computers as an aid to the theorist: Krishna Mohan Parattu on searching for theories to explain the mixing of neutrinos
Like  Save

Focussing on the specific case of building models of neutrino mixing from discrete symmetry groups, we showed that computers, in addition to their important role in the various numerical and algebraic computations required after a theory has been specified, can be used as an effective aid for scientists working on theoretical models.

Could you please first provide the necessary background, an overview of your research area, to help our readers understand your research project?

This is a project on which I worked a few years ago. We were trying to understand how the elementary particles called neutrinos mix, and for this we used computers to scan over various possible theories.

Neutrinos are very interesting particles. They are the lightest particles with non-zero mass. (There are particles with zero mass, like the photons making up light.) We still do not know their masses. To explain why this is the situation, we shall first recap the story of neutrinos thus far. Pauli proposed that there should be a neutral (zero charge) particle accompanying the electron in the nuclear process called beta decay, because otherwise some conservation laws like the law of conservation of energy seemed to be violated.

After the neutron was discovered, this particle was called "neutrino" (meaning "little neutron" in Italian). Soon scientists discovered a heavier cousin of the electron, called the muon. It had the same charge and spin as the electron but was about 200 times heavier. Some decades later, an even heavier cousin was found, called the tau. This one was more than three thousand times heavier than the electron! It turned out that each of these particles came with their own sidekick neutrinos. So now we have the electron neutrino, the muon neutrino and the tau neutrino. All were thought to have zero masses. Then there came the surprising discovery that these neutrinos can change into each other even while traveling through empty space! This phenomenon is called neutrino oscillation and we can only explain it if the three neutrinos have different masses. So at most one neutrino can have zero mass. Scientists use three numbers, called neutrino mixing angles, to describe how fast neutrinos turn into each other. There is also another number, called a phase, which appears because these rotations are done using complex numbers, unlike the rotations in our usual 3D world.

These numbers can be measured from experiments. Neutrino oscillations depend on mass differences of the neutrinos and so we can get that information too. (More accurately, electron, muon and tau neutrinos don’t have precise masses. It is three different combinations of these neutrinos that have three definite masses.) From other experiments, we can place upper limits on the masses.

Photomultiplier tubes in Daya Bay neutrino detector designed to study the oscillation of neutrinos coming from nuclear reactors (Image courtesy: Brookhaven National Laboratory, available at https://www.flickr.com/photos/brookhavenlab/6818362448 licensed under CC BY-NC-ND 2.0 [https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/2.0/])

Describe what was the aim of your research project

Scientists have been trying to come up with some theory to explain why there are three types of “electrons” and neutrinos and to explain the values of the three angles of neutrino oscillations (and the phase). One way to do this is to assume that the interactions of these particles obey some symmetry. Symmetries, finding that certain properties do not change even after some change to the system, have a glorious role in the history of physics. Einstein started from the assumption that the speed of light does not change even if the observer starts moving and gave us the theory of relativity. Emmy Noether’s mathematics showed us how symmetries can tell us why some things are conserved. For example, the law of conservation of energy is related to the fact that the laws of physics do not change with time. The standard model of particle physics is also built upon symmetries and predicted things like the Higgs particle. An extra symmetry added to the standard model may help predict the fact that there are three different kinds of “electrons” (and neutrinos) and may also give us the mixing angles.

Consider a cow. Cows are symmetric creatures. If the right side of our cow is purple then we expect that there is a wrong side that is purple too. Similarly, an extra symmetry could tell us that if the electron exists then muon and tau must also exist. We wanted to follow this idea focussing on predicting the mixing angles. For this, we used groups, structures in maths that are very suited for describing symmetries. Scientists start with a group, which means some sort of symmetry, and then build a model that in the end gives you some mixing angles. If you do it smartly, you can get a model that gives you results within the ranges set by experiment. But this is hard work and one model is generally one research paper. We decided to use computers to do the hard work for us since the process follows well-defined rules. That way, we could have the computer construct thousands of models and give us the models that match with experiments.

Now, symmetries can be continuous or discrete. Continuous symmetries are symmetries under some action that you can perform continuously, for example the symmetry of a circle under rotation. Discrete symmetries deal with symmetries under discrete changes. A square is symmetric under rotations under multiples of 90 degrees but not for any angle in between. Discrete symmetries correspond to discrete groups, which are more manageable than continuous groups. We decided to use a language called GAP, a system for computer algebra that has the maths of groups built in, and interface it with Python language to build models. So, the idea was that GAP will go through a list of groups and pass the information to Python, which will use that information to construct models for each group, calculate the mixing angles and then compare them with experiments.

Water tank with photomultiplier tubes at Super-Kamiokande neutrino detector (Credit: Kamioka Observatory, ICRR(Institute for Cosmic Ray Research), The University of Tokyo)

What were the new results from your research?

Previously, scientists had found that a few discrete groups can give mixing angles within the ranges set by experiment. So, was there anything special about these groups? Or could we use other groups also to construct successful models? We ran the scan and were surprised to find a huge number of models that can match experiments! We found such models for 44 of the 76 groups that we looked at. For each of these groups, we could construct many successful models, sometimes thousands! For example, there was this group that was popular in the literature at that time that we used as our trial group, i.e. the first group to scan over to test if our code was working properly. For that group itself, we could construct 22932 models, of which 4481 matched experiments. If we had taken these models one by one and published a paper every week, we would have had enough material for our whole academic lives! Of course, it is not that easy. Even if you know that a model is successful, it might take some work to write all the details as a research paper. In fact later, after we published this paper, we took one of the successful models (with the smallest group among the 44 successful groups) and analyzed it by hand with another researcher. This was an important check to see if everything was right with our code. The results matched with what we had obtained from the computer and we published that model as a separate research paper.

A 3D map of the models we found. Each point in this space corresponds to some values of the three angles. Each colored dot represents a value for which the computer could construct a theoretical model. The color is a measure of the number of models, with the number increasing from bluish to reddish colors, i.e. as we move along the VIBGYOR spectrum.

Would you like to introduce our readers to your collaborators on this project?

My senior collaborator on this project was Akin Wingerter, a German researcher who was a postdoctoral scholar at Indian Institute of Science, Bangalore when we started working on the project. At that time, I had just finished my MSc in Physics and was spending one year at IISc as a project assistant. We finished it one year later after Akin had moved to France to join LPSC, Grenoble for another postdoc and I had joined IUCAA, Pune for my PhD. Later, for the next paper that derived from this project, we collaborated with Christoph Luhn, who was then a postdoc at the University of Durham.

What are the future prospects in this research direction?

When we published our paper, there was a possibility that one of the mixing angles is zero. But since then, experiments, including the Daya Bay neutrino detector pictured above, have shown that this angle is non-zero. So the allowed values from experiments have changed. Other groups have carried out computer scans with updated experimental values. But they seem to be getting successful models only with a few, very complicated groups. In physics, we generally feel that we are missing something if things get too complicated. Suffice to say, right now there is no suitable model for the mixing angles that the community is happy with. So there is work to be done in this direction. I do not currently work in this area. I did my PhD in the field of gravity and have not worked on neutrinos since 2012, when the second paper in this project came out.


List of References

    Cite this Page as

    Krishna Mohan Parattu, Akin Wingerter, "Frog said to describe its home through song", MachPrinciple, December 14, 2011, https://machprinciple.com/post/frog-said-to-describe-its-home-through-song

    Keywords

    neutrinos computers group theory neutrino oscillation discrete groups particle physics neutrino mixing angles family symmetries lepton families standard model of particle physics

    0Likes

    0Comments

    Like   Share Share

    Authors Involved

      Institutes Involved

        Chandigarh Sets New Standard with Free Education Till 18 for Children with Disabilities - The Logical Indian

        Chandigarh Launches Pioneering 2025 Education Policy Guaranteeing Free, Inclusive Schooling Till 18 for Over 3,000 Children with Disabilities....

        How hiring individuals with intellectual disabilities mutually benefits hotels, employees

        The advantages of hiring individuals with intellectual and developmental disabilities go beyond helping hotels fill open roles, according to Penn......

        https://news.asu.edu/20250724-environment-and-sustainability-new-global-study-shows-freshwater-disappearing-alarming

        New findings from studying over two decades of satellite observations reveal that the Earth's continents have experienced unprecedented freshw......

        https://news.arizona.edu/news/tiny-fossil-suggests-spiders-and-their-relatives-originated-sea

        In a study led by Nicholas Strausfeld at the University of Arizona and published in Current Biology, researchers from the U.S. and United......

        Why some heavy drinkers develop advanced liver disease, while others do not

        A new study from Keck Medicine of USC finds that heavy drinkers with either diabetes, high blood pressure or a high waist circumference are as......

        Pregnancy complications linked to cardiovascular disease in the family

        It is well known that complications during pregnancy, such as high blood pressure and premature labour, increase the risk of cardiovascular......

        Deep learning to increase accessibility, ease of heart imaging

        A new deep learning technique developed by researchers at Washington University in St. Louis with collaborators from Cleveland Clinic and......

        A Diabetes, Heart Failure, and Kidney Disease Medication is the First of Its Kind to Significantly Reduce Both Heart Attacks and Strokes

         Sotagliflozin, a drug recently approved by the Food and Drug Administration to treat type 2 diabetes and kidney disease with additional......

        Regular dental flossing may lower risk of stroke from blood clots, irregular heartbeats

         Flossing your teeth at least once a week may be linked to a lower risk of stroke caused by a blood clot blocking brain blood flow and irregu......

        Stroke warning sign acronyms drive 911 calls, F.A.S.T. leads in symptom recall for public

         When it comes to prompting people to call 911 at the first sign of stroke, both F.A.S.T. and BE-FAST stroke warning signs acronyms were......

        An Arctic ‘beyond recognition’ by 2100

        A new review paper, published in Science on February 6, 2025, highlights these changes and their far-reaching implications. The paper......

        Peatlands and mangroves key to reducing carbon emissions in Southeast Asia, finds international study

        Conserving and restoring Southeast Asia’s carbon-rich peatlands and mangroves could mitigate more than 50 per cent of the region’s land-us......

        New play in the chemical-reaction playbook uncovered

        The reactions of organic compounds — those containing carbon, hydrogen, oxygen and a few other elements — are limited by the bonding......

        A new organometallic compound challenges a fundamental principle of textbook chemistry

        For many transition metal complexes, they are most stable when surrounded by 18 formal valence electrons. This is a chemical rule of thumb on......

        Mental health from supermarket shelves? This is the evidence we have about over-the-counter herbal products and dietary supplements used for depressio

        Depression is increasingly common, to the extent that it is sometimes described as an epidemic. In the UK, 11.3% of people report mild depress......

        Deep-sea fish confirmed as a significant source of ocean carbonate

        “Mesopelagic fish live in deep, cold, high-pressure environments, and until now, it was unclear if they produced carbonate like shallow......

        Simulating the unthinkable: Models show nuclear winter food production plunge

         A nuclear winter is a theoretical concept, but if the climate scenario expected to follow a large-scale nuclear war, in which smoke and soot......

        Mental health from supermarket shelves? This is the evidence we have about over-the-counter herbal products and dietary supplements used for depressio

        Depression is increasingly common, to the extent that it is sometimes described as an epidemic. In the UK, 11.3% of people report mild depress......

        Nighttime pistachio snacking may reshape gut microbiome in prediabetic adults

        A new study led by Kristina Petersen, associate professor of nutritional sciences at Penn State, determined that nighttime pistachio consumpt......

        Stevia leaf extract has potential as anticancer treatment, researchers find

        “Globally, the incidence and mortality rates of pancreatic cancer continue to rise, with a five-year survival rate of less than 10%,” said......